When the summer sun starts beating down, a little dip in a pool can’t be beaten. But picking the right type of pool can be difficult — especially if you’re weighing an above-ground vs. in-ground pool. Each of them have their own pros and cons, and knowing their differences can help you make the right decision. In this blog, we will compare both types of pools in terms of their costs, installation processes, pros, cons, and lifestyle suitability. By the end, you’ll have an idea of what pool is right for your backyard.
What is an Above-Ground Pool?
An above-ground pool is a temporary or semi-permanent pool that rests on the ground surface and is not buried into the earth. These pools usually have steel, resin or hybrid frames and a liner that holds the water. They range in size and shape from circular and rectangular to a host of configurations, and they are often chosen for their relative affordability and easy installation.
Installation Process
You can install an above-ground pool in half the time of in-ground pools, and it is much easier. It tends to take a few days for set up, particularly for the DYI folks. Its drainage and overflow capacity is instead based on the pool’s shape, as you would just assemble the frame, add the pool liner, and fill it with water. Above-ground pools are also often sold to install yourself, further reducing costs.
What is an In-Ground Pool?
This type of pool is built straight in the earth, requiring excavation and a more complex installation. These pools are permanent, and it can take weeks if not months to install them. Concrete, fiberglass, and vinyl liner are among the materials available for building a swimming pool in the ground, each with benefits of its own.
Installation Process
Unlike above-ground models, in-ground models must be installed by professionals. That process involves excavating a hole in your yard, building the pool structure, plumbing, and finishing it out with tiles, plaster or a fiberglass shell. Although this process takes more time and is more detailed, it will provide a pool that is going to last you for many years.
Pros of Above-Ground Pools
Cost-Effective
Above-ground pools cost much less than in-ground pools. The initial purchase cost is often only a fraction of the cost of an in-ground pool and they have lower maintenance costs too. Installation is significantly cheaper as well, particularly if you opt to install it yourself.
Easy Installation
As stated, above-ground pools are far faster and simpler to set up. Most times, it only takes a weekend to have your pool swim-ready. They can be a great option for people who want a pool today and don’t want to wait.
Portability
The largest advantage of above-ground swimming pools is their versatility. You can dismantle your pool and take it with you if you move. This also makes above-ground pools suitable for renters or anyone who doesn’t want a permanent installation in their yard.
Variety of Sizes
Above-ground pools are available in various sizes making them fit to fill most spaces. No matter whether you have a tiny outdoor space or a big garden, there are above-ground swimming pools to fit.
Cons of Above-Ground Pools
Aesthetic Limitations
Above-ground pools might get the job done, but they aren’t exactly an aesthetic touch. Their bulky, metal frames can be at odds with the look of a well-landscaped backyard. An above-ground pool may not be the right choice if curb appeal and luxury are at the top of your wish list.
Durability
An above ground pool generally does not last as long as an in-ground pool. The frame materials, particularly steel, are prone to rust over time, and the liner may need to be changed every few years.
Limited Customization
Above-ground pools are less customizable than in-ground pools. You’re mostly restricted to standard shapes and sizes, and you can’t embed the pool into your landscaping the way you can with an in-ground pool.
Pros of In-Ground Pools
Aesthetic Appeal
In-ground pools on the other hand, are considered a luxury addition in any backyard. Depending on the design chosen, these pools can better blend in with the landscaping, making the pool area feel more custom and visually aesthetic. Quantities (fiberglass, concrete or vinyl) of materials create countless design options.
Customization
Inground pools offer a high degree of customization as one of their top benefits. In-ground pools can be constructed to your specifications—if you prefer a freeform pool, infinity edge, lap pool, etc. You can also include features such as waterfalls, lighting or even swim-up bars.
Long-Term Investment
The lifespan of an in-ground pool is significantly longer than that of an above-ground pool. An in-ground pool can last decades with regular maintenance. They also provide value to your property, which makes them a sound investment if you decide to sell your home in the future.
Durability
Above-ground pools are not as durable as in-ground pools. They are built from materials (particularly concrete and fiberglass) designed to take serious punishment for decades.
Cons of In-Ground Pools
High Cost
The biggest drawback to in-ground pools is their cost. The upfront cost is considerably greater, with some in-ground pools costing tens of thousands of dollars. The complexity of the pool and its equipment generally make maintenance costs higher, too.
Long Installation Time
An in-ground pool is a long-term project. Depending on how big, designer, or complex the pool is; installation can take from several weeks to a few months. That means you’ll have to wait while the pool is being built.
Permanent
In-ground pools are permanent unlike above-ground pools. Once they’re in, there’s no taking them with you if you choose to relocate. This can be a downside if you don’t intend to remain in your home long-term.
Comparison of costs: Above-ground vs. In-Ground Pools
Initial Cost
Above-ground pools: $1,500 to $15,000, depending on size and materials
In-Ground Pools: Generally range from around $20,000 to over $100,000, depending on size, materials, and customization features.
Maintenance Cost
Above-Ground Pools: Maintenance for above-ground pools is less expensive than in-ground pools, and annual costs typically range from $300 to $1,500.
In-Ground Pools: In-ground pools have maintenance costs of about $1,500 to $5,000 per year, which is considerable.
Resale Value
Above-Ground Pools: Typically do not provide much resale value for a property.
In-Ground Pools: May boost your home value if the pool is well-maintained and blends nicely with the landscaping.
Best Fit for Each Type of Pool
Above-Ground Pools: The ideal choice for families short on space in their backyard or renters wanting a more temporary pool hiring solution. They’re also perfect for people who don’t want a permanent commitment to a pool.
In-Ground Pools — BEST FOR: Homeowners Who Have Money to Spend on an Investment | Best for Luxury & Permanence They’re ideal for people who have a lot of people over or who want to raise the value of their home.
Final Words: Which Pool Is The Best Fit For You?
The choice between an above-ground and in-ground pool depends primarily on your budget, available space, and long-term plans. If you’re interested in a budget-friendly, short-term, or easy-to-set-up choice, an above-ground pool might work for you. But if you’re prepared for a long-term project and desire a personalized and high-end pool, an in-ground pool is the route to take.
Regardless of which pool you go with, both provide a good means to enjoy the summer months. Keep in mind your needs, do your research and choose the pool that would best suit your lifestyle.
